Chapter 14
Q. 14.6.3
Q. 14.6.3
(Cambridge University Engineering Tripos: Preliminary Examination for Part I (1975).) Figs. 14.6-7(a) and (b) show respectively the dimensions of a propped uniform cantilever and its cross-section.
(a) Determine the plastic moment of resistance of the beam section if the yield stress of the material is 250 N/mm2 in tension and in compression.
(b) If the load W may be applied at any position within the span, determine the minimum value of W that will cause collapse.
(c) If the load W is removed just after the formation of the collapse plastic hinges, sketch the shapes of the bending moment and shear force diagrams after the removal of the load.

Step-by-Step
Verified Solution
(a)The neutral axis divides the cross section into two parts of equal area as in Fig. 14.6-8(a)
\qquad \begin{matrix}\text{ Therefore }: \ \text{Lever arm } \ & =(10+5)/2=7.5 \ mm \\ \text{Plastic moment } \ M_{p} & =10\times 10\times 250\times 7.5 \\ \quad & = \underline{0.188\ kN\ m } \\ \end{matrix}(b) Consider the mechanism in Fig. 14.6-8(b), where the position of the plastic hinge B is defined by the variable x.
The work equation is
or
\qquad W = \frac{1+x}{x(1-x)}\frac{M_{p}}{L}We do not know the value of x, but we do know that the required value of x is such as to make W a minimum.
\hspace{5em} \frac{dW}{dx}=0\ gives\ x^{2}+2x-1=0Therefore x = 0.414
and W=730 N
(c) In the absence of external applied load, the beam is acted on by support reactions only (see Fig. 14.6-8(c)).
Suppose the (unknown) support reactions are M and R. The only possible
shape of the bending moment diagram is a triangle (Fig. 14.6-8(d)); the only possible shape of the shear force diagram is a rectangle (Fig. 14.6-8(e)).
COMMENTS
(1) With reference to the mechanism in Fig. 14.6-8(b) it is interesting to note that (and the reader should verify this by elastic analysis) the maximum elastic moment at B is 0.174 WL and occurs when x = 0.366 L, as shown in Fig. 14.6-9(a).
However, the reader must not be tempted into thinking that the correct mechanism is that in Fig. 14.6-9(b). As we saw in part (b) of the solution above, the hinge B in the correct mechanism is at 0.414 L from A.
(2) With reference to Part (c) of the question, a common error is to think that
the residual moment diagram has a ‘kink’, at the plastic hinge position.
(2) With reference to Part (c) of the question, a common error is to think that
the residual moment diagram has a ‘kink’, at the plastic hinge position.



