It is desired to separate a mixture of two industrial enzymes, lysozyme and catalase, in a dilute, aqueous solution by a gel filtration membrane. A mesoporous membrane with cylindrical pores of 30 nm diameter is available (Figure 24.9). The following separation factor (α) for the process is proposed:
\alpha={\frac{D_{A e}}{D_{B e}}}
Determine the separation factor for this process. The properties of each enzyme as reported by \mathrm{Tanford}^{21} are given below.
The transport of large enzyme molecules through pores filled with liquid water represents a hindered diffusion process. The reduced pore diameters for lysozyme and catalase are
\varphi_{A}={\frac{d_{s, A}}{d_{\mathrm{pore}}}}={\frac{4.12\,\mathrm{nm}}{30.0\,\mathrm{nm}}}=0.137\,\mathrm{and}\,\varphi_{B}={\frac{d_{s, B}}{d_{\mathrm{pore}}}}={\frac{10.44\,\mathrm{nm}}{30.0\,\mathrm{nm}}}=0.348
For lysozyme, F_{1}(\varphi_{A}), by equation (24-64), and F_{2}(\varphi_{A}), by the Renkin equation (24-65), are
F_{2}(\varphi)=1-2.104\varphi+2.09\varphi^{3}-0.95\varphi^{5} (24-65)
F_{1}(\varphi_{A})=(1-\varphi_{A})^{2}=(1-0.137)^{2}=0.744\\
F_{2}(\varphi_{A})\,=\,1-2.104\varphi_{A}+2.09\varphi_{A}^{3}-0.95\varphi_{A}^{5}\\
=\;1-2.104(0.137)+2.090(0.137)^{3}-0.95(0.137)^{5}=0.716
The effective diffusivity of lysozyme in the pore, D_{Ae} , is estimated by equation (24-62)
\frac{D_{A e}}{D_{A B}^{o}}=F_{1}(\varphi)F_{2}(\varphi) (24-62)
D_{A e}=D_{A-\mathrm{H}_{2}O}F_{1}(\varphi_{A})F_{2}(\varphi_{A})=1.04\times10^{-6}\frac{\mathrm{cm}^{2}}{\mathrm{s}}(0.744)(0.716)=5.54\times10^{-7}\frac{\mathrm{cm}^{2}}{\mathrm{s}}
Likewise, for catalase F_{1}(\varphi_{B})=0.425,F_{2}(\varphi_{B})=0.351,\;\mathrm{and}\;D_{B e}=6.12\times10^{-8}\;\mathrm{cm}^{2}/s. Finally, the separation factor is
\alpha={\frac{D_{A e}}{D_{B e}}}={\frac{5.54\times10^{-7}\,\mathrm{cm}^{2}/s}{6.12\times10^{-8}\,\mathrm{cm}^{2}/s}}=9.06
It is interesting to compare the value above with \alpha^{\prime}, the ratio of molecular diffusivities at infinite dilution:
\alpha^{\prime}={\frac{D_{A-H_{2}O}}{D_{B-\mathrm{HzO}}}}={\frac{1.04\times10^{-6}\mathrm{cm}^{2}/{\mathrm{s}}}{4.1\times10^{-7}\mathrm{cm}^{2}/{\mathrm{s}}}}=1.75
The small pore diameter enhances the value for \alpha, because the diffusion of the large catalase molecule is significantly hindered inside the pore relative to the smaller lysozyme molecule.