Question 14.2: Figure 14.11 shows a gravity retaining wall for a granular (...

Figure 14.11 shows a gravity retaining wall for a granular (c′ = 0) backfill. The same soil is present at the bottom of the wall and on the left. The unit weight and the friction angle of the backfill are 18.5 kN/m³ and 35°, respectively. The unit weight of the concrete is 24.0 kN/m³. Determine the factors of safety with respect to overturning, sliding, and bearing capacity failure.

14.11
The blue check mark means that this solution has been answered and checked by an expert. This guarantees that the final answer is accurate.
Learn more on how we answer questions.

The retaining wall and the soil regions of interest are divided into the rectangles and triangles shown in Figure 14.12 for case of computation of the weights and moment arms.
For φ′ = 35° and α = 15°, we find from Table 11.2 that K_a = 0.2968. Thus,
P_a=\frac{1}{2}\gamma H^{\prime 2}K_a=\frac{1}{2}(18.5)(6.54)^2(0.2968)= 117.4 kN/m
P_h=P_a \cos \alpha = 113.4 kN/m
P_v=P_a \sin \alpha= 30.4 kN/m

Section Weight (kN/m) Moment arm from C (m) Moment about C (kN⋅m/m)
1 (0.5)(1.5)(6.0)(24.0)=108.0 1.0 108.0
2 (0.5)(6.0)(24.0)=72.0 1.75 126.0
3 (0.5)(2.0)(6.0)(24.0)=144.0 2.67 384.5
4 (0.5)(2.0)(6.0)(18.5)=111.0 3.33 369.6
5 (0.5)(2.0)(0.54)(18.5)=10.0 3.33 33.3
 P_v=30.4 4.0 121.6
 \sum V=475.4 \sum M_R=1143.0

Stability with Respect to Overturning
The overturning moment is
M_O=P_h\frac{H^\prime}{3}=113.4\times 2.18= 247.2 kN/m
The resisting moment is
\sum M_R = 1143.0 kN/m
Therefore,
FS_{(overturning)} = \frac{\sum M_g}{M_O}=\frac{1143.0}{247.2} = 4.62
Stability with Respect to Sliding
For φ′ = 35°, from Eq. 11.28,
K_p=\tan^2\left(45+\frac{\phi^\prime}{2}\right)= 3.690
P_p=\frac{1}{2}\gamma D^2 K_p=\frac{1}{2}(18.5)(1.0)^2(3.690)= 34.1 kN/m
Take δ′ as {}^2/3 φ′. So δ′ = 23.3°, we have
FS_{(sliding)} =\frac{ (\sum V) \tan \delta^\prime+ P_p}{P_h}=\frac{475.4\times  \tan 23.3 + 34.1}{113.4} = 2.11
Stability with Respect to Bearing Capacity Failure
e = \frac{B}{2}-\frac{ \sum M_R – \sum M_O}{\sum V} =\frac{ 4.0}{2} -\frac{ 1143.0 – 247.2}{475.4} = 0.116 m \lt \frac{B}{6} \left(=\frac{4}{6}=0.67 m\right)
From Eq. (14.11),
q_{max} = q_{toe} = \frac{\sum V}{B}\left(1+\frac{6e}{B}\right)=\frac{475.4}{4.0} \left(1+\frac{(6)(0.116)}{4.0}\right)= 139.5 kN/m²
In granular soil, Eq. 14.13 becomes
q_u^\prime = q N_qF_{qd} F_{qi} +0.5 \gamma B^\prime N_\gamma F_{\gamma d}F_{\gamma i}
where, B′ = B – 2e = 3.768 m and q = γD = (18.5)(1.0) = 18.5 kN/m².
For φ′ = 35°, from Table 12.1

φ′ N_c N_q N_\gamma φ′ N_c N_q N_\gamma
0 5.14 1.00 0.00 23 18.05 8.66 8.20
1 5.38 1.09 0.07 24 19.32 9.60 9.44
2 5.63 1.20 0.15 25 20.72 10.66 10.88
3 5.90 1.31 0.24 26 22.25 11.85 12.54
4 6.19 1.43 0.34 27 23.94 13.20 14.47
5 6.49 1.57 0.45 28 25.80 14.72 16.72
6 6.81 1.72 0.57 29 27.86 16.44 19.34
7 7.16 1.88 0.71 30 30.14 18.40 22.40
8 7.53 2.06 0.86 31 32.67 20.63 25.99
9 7.92 2.25 1.03 32 35.49 23.18 30.22
10 8.35 2.47 1.22 33 38.64 26.09 35.19
11 8.80 2.71 1.44 34 42.16 29.44 41.06
12 9.28 2.97 1.69 35 46.12 33.30 48.03
13 9.81 3.26 1.97 36 50.59 37.75 56.31
14 10.37 3.59 2.29 37 55.63 42.92 66.19
15 10.98 3.94 2.65 38 61.35 48.93 78.03
16 11.63 4.34 3.06 39 67.87 55.96 92.25
17 12.34 4.77 3.53 40 75.31 64.20 109.41
18 13.10 5.26 4.07 41 83.86 73.90 130.22
19 13.93 5.80 4.68 42 93.71 85.38 155.55
20 14.83 6.40 5.39 43 105.11 99.02 186.54
21 15.82 7.07 6.20 44 118.37 115.31 224.64
22 16.88 7.82 7.13 45 133.88 134.88 271.76

N_q = 33.30 and N_\gamma = 48.03. Hence,
F_{qd}=1+2\tan\phi^\prime(1-\sin \phi^\prime)^2\frac{D_f}{B}=1+2 \tan 35(1- \sin 35)^2 \frac{1}{4}= 1.07
F_{\gamma d} =1
\Psi=\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{P_a \cos \alpha}{\sum V}\right)=\tan^{-1}\left(\frac{113.4}{475.4}\right)=13.4°
F_{qi}=\left(1-\frac{\Psi}{90}\right)^2=\left(1-\frac{13.4}{90}\right)= 0.72
F_{\gamma i}=\left(1+\frac{\Psi}{\phi^\prime}\right)^2=\left(1-\frac{15}{35}\right)^2= 0.33
q_u = (18.5)(33.30)(1.07)(0.72) + (0.5)(18.5)(3.768)(48.03)(1.0)(0.33)= 1027.0 kN/m²
FS_{(bearing  capacity)} =\frac{q_u^\prime}{q_{max}}=\frac{1027.0}{139.5} = 7.4

14.12

Related Answered Questions