Question 10.1: A machine has an initial cost of $10 000. Being a special-pu......

A machine has an initial cost of $10 000. Being a special-purpose custom-built unit, it can only be resold as scrap at $500, no matter what its age. The machine has a 10-year service life. The annual operating costs are $2000 for each of the first two years, with an increase of $600 per year thereafter. The MARR is 10%. When is the optimum time to retire the machine?

Step-by-Step
The 'Blue Check Mark' means that this solution was answered by an expert.
Learn more on how do we answer questions.

The cost curve for this type of problem is the net EUAC, evaluated at the MARR, as a function of time.

From Section 7.4, we know that the net EUAC will be made up of two components: the capital recovery cost,

CR(j)=(\$10,000-\$500)(A/P,10\%,j)+(0.10)(\$500)          (1)

and the equivalent annualized operating cost,

A(j)=\$1400+\$600(A/G,10\%,j)+\$600(P/F,10\%,1)(A/P,10\%,j)       (2)

In deriving (I), the constancy of the salvage value was used; in deriving (2), the gradient series was extended backwards by writing the first year’s cost as $1400+ $600. In both expressions, j is the time, in years; thus, to keep the machine for 4 years would cost the company CR(4) + A(4) per year.
Substituting j = 1,2, . . . , 10 in (1) and (2), we generate Table 10-1; the points are plotted in Fig. 10-1. The data show that the machine should be retired at the end of 7 years.
The time interval for which the EUAC of an asset is smallest (7 years, for the machine of Example 10.1) is called the economic life of the asset. As we have seen, the economic life is given analytically as that value j* at which

EUAC(j)=CR(j)+A(j)

is minimized.
The concept of economic life may also furnish the basis for a replacement decision, particularly when service lives are not precisely known, when salvage values in each year are not known, or when the equipment obsolesces rapidly.

Table 10-1
Years of
Service Life, j
CR(j) A(j) EUAC(j) =CR(j)+A(j)
1 $10 500.00 $2 000.00 $12 500.00
2 5 523.81 2000.00 7 523.81
3 3 870.05 2181.24 6 051.29
4 3 046.97 2400.77 5 447.74
5 2 556.10 2629.99 5 186.09
6 2 231.30 2859.40 5 090.70
7 2 001.40 3085.07 5 086.47 = min.
8 1 830.68 3304.85 5 135.53
9 1 699.58 3518.12 5 217.70
10 1596.13 3724.16 5 320.29
FIG10.1

Related Answered Questions