Question 19.7: Dual-Duct System Part-Load Operation A dual-duct conditioned......

Dual-Duct System Part-Load Operation

A dual-duct conditioned single zone has a peak heating load of 7.50 kW (25,600 Btu/h) and a peak sensible cooling load of 6.50 kW (22,200 Btu/h). The zone temperature is to be held at 25°C (77°F) (also assumed for simplicity to be the return air temperature).

The two duct supply temperatures at the zone are 40°C (104°F) and 14°C (57°F). If the cooling load is 3.50 kW (11,950 Btu/h) at a part-load point, what are the heating and cooling rates at the zone?
Given: Hot and cold deck and room temperatures:
Tdb,4=40°C,Tdb,3=14°C,Tzone=25°CT_{db,4} = 40°C, T_{db,3} = 14°C, T_{zone} = 25°C
Design peak loads: Q˙max,cool=6.5 kW,Q˙max,heat=7.5 kW\dot{Q}_{max,cool} = 6.5  kW, \dot{Q}_{max,heat} = 7.5  kW

Part load: Q˙part,cool=3.5 kW\dot{Q}_{part,cool} = 3.5  kW
Figure: Figure 19.16b (consider only one of the zones).
Assumptions: Ignore the air temperature rise across the fan and the heat losses and gains in the ductwork.
Consider only sensible loads for simplicity.
Find: Q˙cc,Q˙hc\dot{Q}_{cc}, \dot{Q}_{hc}

19.16
Step-by-Step
The 'Blue Check Mark' means that this solution was answered by an expert.
Learn more on how do we answer questions.

The solution involves two steps. First, the airflow at peak load is determined. Since the dualduct system is a constant-volume system, this same flow will apply to part-load conditions.
Second, solve for the heating and cooling rates at part load.

The airflow rate needed for peak heating is found from Equation 19.12

V˙a,heat=Q˙space,heatρaca(Tdb,supply – Tdb,space)\dot{V}_{a,heat} = \frac{\dot{Q}_{space,heat}}{\rho_{a} c_{a} (T_{db,supply}  –  T_{db,space})}                (19.12)

m˙a,hc,peak=7.5 kW(40 – 25)°C×1.0 kJ/(kgK)=0.50 kg/s\dot{m}_{a,hc,peak} = \frac{7.5  kW}{(40  –  25)°C \times 1.0  kJ/(kg \cdot K)} = 0.50  kg/s

and for peak cooling, the airflow rate is

m˙a,cc,peak=6.5 kW(25 – 14)°C ×1.5 kJ/(kgK)=0.59 kg/s\dot{m}_{a,cc,peak} = \frac{6.5  kW}{(25  –  14)°C  \times 1.5  kJ/(kg \cdot K)} = 0.59  kg/s

The higher flow rate (0.59 kg/s) will be used for both heating and cooling since the constant-volume dual-duct system uses a single constant-volume fan.
The supply air temperature entering the zone at part load (3.5 kW cooling) is found from a sensible heat balance

Q˙part,cool=3.5 kW=0.59 kg/s×1.0 kJ/(kgK)×(25 – T5)°C  \dot{Q}_{part,cool} = 3.5  kW = 0.59  kg/s \times 1.0  kJ/(kg \cdot K) \times (25  –  T_{5})°C 

from which the supply air temperature is found to be T5=19.1°CT_{5} = 19.1°C.
At the part-load condition, we use Equation 19.18

m˙a,cc,B=m˙a,B(Tdb,4 – Tdb,5B)(Tdb,4 – Tdb,3)\dot{m}_{a,cc,B} = \dot{m}_{a,B} \frac{(T_{db,4}  –  T_{db,5B})}{(T_{db,4}  –  T_{db,3})}   and    m˙a,hc,B=m˙a,B – m˙a,cc,B\dot{m}_{a,hc,B} = \dot{m}_{a,B}  –  \dot{m}_{a,cc,B}             (19.18)

m˙a,cc=0.59 kg/s×(40 – 19.1)°C(40 – 14)°C=0.475 kg/s\dot{m}_{a,cc} = 0.59  kg/s \times \frac{(40  –  19.1) °C}{(40  –  14)°C} = 0.475  kg/s

and m˙a,hc=0.59 – 0.475=0.115 kg/s \dot{m}_{a,hc} = 0.59  –  0.475 = 0.115  kg/s
Finally, the cooling and heating coil loads are

Q˙cc=0.475 kg/s×1.0 kJ/(kgK)×(25 – 14)°C\dot{Q}_{cc} = 0.475  kg/s \times 1.0  kJ/(kg \cdot K) \times (25  –  14) °C

= 5.23  kW (17,850  Btu/h)

Q˙hc=0.115 kg/s×1.0 kJ/(kgK)×(40 – 25)°C\dot{Q}_{hc} = 0.115  kg/s \times 1.0  kJ /(kg \cdot K) \times (40  –  25)°C

= 1.73  kW (5900  Btu/h)
The difference between these two coil loads is the 3.5 kW cooling rate, as required by the problem statement.
Comments
This example illustrates the key problem with dual-duct systems from an energy viewpoint. The heating energy in this example is not needed at all.
However, it is present due to the system’s basic configuration requiring constant airflow. To compound the problem, not 3.50 kW but 5.23 kW of cooling is needed, since the unwanted 1.7 kW of heat must be extracted by the cooling system in addition to the zone’s load. The energy waste is obvious.

Related Answered Questions