Holooly Plus Logo

Question 17.8: Estimate the maximum sensitive response for the industrial b......

Estimate the maximum sensitive response for the industrial building of Example 17.1 using Newmark–Hall design spectra for an anticipated ground acceleration of 0.308g and for a damping factor of 0.05. Compare the results with the maximum response obtained from time history analysis.

fig 17.23
fig 17.24
fig 17.25
fig 17.26
Step-by-Step
The 'Blue Check Mark' means that this solution was answered by an expert.
Learn more on how do we answer questions.

Damping = 5%

(i) NS direction, T = 0.567 s

From chart (see Fig. 17.23), spectra value S_d=6.35~ cm ; S_{p v}=71.12 ~cm / s; S_{p a}=784.35 ~cm / s ^2.

Maximum base shear = m S_{p a}

                                         = 131 697.2 × 7.843

                                        = 1032.9 kN

Column bending moment =\frac{3~ E I S_d}{h^2}

                                                  =\frac{3 ~\times ~200~ \times ~10^9~ \times~ 8.6997~ \times ~10^{-5} ~\times ~0.063}{4.2672^2}

                                                  = 181.9 Nm

(ii)     EW direction

          S_d=20~ mm

        S_{pv} = 393.7~ mm/s

        S_{pa} = 7.843~ mm/s²

         ω_{n} = 20~ rad/s

            T = 0.313

        Maximum base shear = m S_{p a}

                                                 = 1032.9 kN

        Axial force in rod = \frac{E A~ \cos \theta}{L} S d

                                       =\frac{506.7~ \times~ 10^{-6} ~\times~ 200~ \times~ 10^9 ~\times ~0.8712}{8.73} 0.02

                                       = 202.20 kN

    Comparison of the maximum response obtained from time history analysis response spectra and design spectrum analysis is presented in Table 17.4 for NS direction. There is a considerable discrepancy between the results of response spectrum and design spectrum. The former represents the response to a specific earthquake while the latter represents predicted response to any earthquake.

Table 17.4 Comparison of response and design spectral values
Response quantity Response
spectrum
Design
spectrum
%
error
Relative displacement 0.045m 0.063 m 40
Relative velocity 0.5 m/s 0.711 42.2
Max. absolute acceleration 5.8 m/s² 7.843 m/s² 35
Base shear 725 kN 1032.9 kN 42.3
Bending moment in columns 128.8 N/m 189.12 N.m 46.8

Related Answered Questions