Calculation of the return on capital employed Carbon plc is planning to buy a new

Question

Calculation of the return on capital employed

Carbon plc is planning to buy a new machine and has found two which meet its needs. Each machine has an expected life of five years. Machine 1 would generate annual cash flows (receipts less payments) of £210,000 and would cost £570,000. Its scrap value at the end of five years would be £70,000. Machine 2 would generate annual cash flows of £510,000 and would cost £1,616,000. The scrap value of this machine at the end of five years would be £301,000. Carbon plc uses the straight-line method of depreciation and has a target return on capital employed of 20 per cent.
Calculate the return on capital employed for both Machine 1 and Machine 2 on an average investment basis and state which machine you would recommend, giving reasons.

Accepted Answer

[latex]\begin{array}{lc} ext{For Machine 1:} &£\ ext { Total cash flow }=210,000 imes 5= & 1,050,000 \ ext { Total depreciation }=570,000-70,000= & \underline{500,000} \ ext { Total accounting profit } & \underline{550,000} \ ext { Average annual accounting profit }=550,000 / 5= & £ 110,000 ext { per year } \ ext { Average investment }=(570,000+70,000) / 2= & 3320,000 \ ext { Return on capital employed }=100 imes(110,000 / 320,000)= & 34.4 \%\end{array}[/latex]

[latex]\begin{array}{lc} ext { For Machine 2: } & £ \ ext { Total cash flow }=510,000 imes 5= & 2,550,000 \ ext { Total depreciation }=1,616,000-301,000= &\underline{1,315,000} \ ext { Total accounting profit } & \underline{1,235,000} \ ext { Average annual accounting profit }=1,235,000 / 5= & ext{£247,000 per year} \ ext { Average investment }=(1,616,000+301,000) / 2= & £958,500 \ ext { Return on capital employed }=100 imes(247,000 / 958,500)= &25.8 \%\end{array}[/latex]

Both machines have a return on capital employed greater than the target rate and so are financially acceptable, but as only one machine is to be purchased, the recommendation is that Machine 1 should be chosen, as it has a higher return on capital employed than Machine 2.

Question 6.EX.2.1: Calculation of the return on capital employed Carbon plc i...

Related Answered Questions

Calculation of internal rates of return Clement plc is evaluating three investment ...

Verified Answer:

Calculation of the net present value Clement plc is evaluating three investment ...

Verified Answer:

Three investment projects have the following net cash flows. Decide which of them should be accepted using the NPV decision rule if the discount rate to be applied is 12 per cent. ...

Verified Answer:

Calculate the return on capital employed (average investment basis) for the following projects, and show which would be chosen if the target ROCE is 12 per cent and there is zero scrap value. ...

Verified Answer:

Explain the distinction between hard and soft capital rationing, and outline the reasons why these conditions might occur. ...

Verified Answer:

What techniques can be used to determine the optimum investment schedule for a company under conditions of capital rationing? ...

Verified Answer:

Discuss the problem of choosing between mutually exclusive projects with respect to their net present values and internal rates of return. ...

Verified Answer:

Explain how NPV and IRR deal with non-conventional cash flows. ...

Verified Answer:

List the advantages of the net present value investment appraisal method. ...

Verified Answer:

Explain the shortcomings of return on capital employed as an investment appraisal method and suggest reasons why it may be used by managers. ...

Verified Answer: