Question 17.4: Expense Recognition for an Information Service Provider Thom...
Expense Recognition for an Information Service Provider
Thomson Corporation, based in Canada, is one of the world’s leading information services providers. The software industry is an interesting sector to examine because it allows considerable discretion with respect to capitalization decisions. Software providers are allowed to capitalize costs associated with software development and then amortize these costs over a period in which the product is expected to be sold. Thomson’s income statement for the year ended 31 December 2006, along with selected notes related to its treatment of software development costs, is presented below.
Note 1: Summary of Significant Accounting Policies: Computer Software
Capitalized Software for Internal Use
Certain costs incurred in connection with the development of software to be used internally are capitalized once a project has progressed beyond a conceptual, preliminary stage to that of application development. Costs which qualify for capitalization include both internal and external costs, but are limited to those that are directly related to the specific project. The capitalized amounts, net of accumulated amortization, are included in “Computer software, net” in the consolidated balance sheet. These costs are amortized over their expected useful lives, which range from three to ten years. The amortization expense is included in “Depreciation” in the consolidated statement of earnings.
Capitalized Software to Be Marketed
In connection with the development of software that is intended to be marketed to customers, certain costs are capitalized once technological feasibility of the product is established and a market for the product has been identified. The capitalized amounts, net of accumulated amortization, are also included in “Computer software, net” in the consolidated balance sheet. The capitalized amounts are amortized over the expected period of benefit, not to exceed three years, and this amortization expense is included in “Cost of sales, selling, marketing, general and administrative expenses” in the consolidated statement of earnings.
Note 12: Computer Software
Computer software consists of the following:
The amortization charge for internal use computer software in 2006 was $241 million (2005, $224 million) and is included in “Depreciation” in the consolidated statement of earnings. The amortization charge for software intended to be marketed was $25 million (2005, $21 million) and is included in “Cost of sales, selling, marketing, general and administrative expenses” in the consolidated statement of earnings.
Based on the information given, address the following problems:
1. Contrast Thomson’s recognition of software related costs in 2006 with the actual cash spent acquiring and developing the software.
2. Estimate Thomson’s 2006 operating profit and earnings from continuing operations assuming Thomson expensed all software related costs when the related cash flows occurred.
3. Contrast the implications for the cash fl ow statement from expensing software development costs rather than capitalizing and amortizing them.
4. Many analysts use EV/EBITDA (enterprise value divided by earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) as a valuation measure for software companies. Enterprise value is simply the sum of the market capitalization and the book value of outstanding debt. Critique the use of this measure when software related costs are being capitalized.
Thomson Corporation: Consolidated Statement of Earnings (US$ millions except per-common-share amounts) |
||
Year ended 31 December | ||
2006 | 2005 | |
Revenues | 6,641 | 6,173 |
Cost of sales, selling, marketing, general and administrative expenses | (4,702) | (4,351) |
Depreciation (Notes 11 and 12) | (439) | (414) |
Amortization (Note 13) | \underline{(242)} | \underline{ (236)} |
Operating profit | 1,258 | 1,172 |
Net other income (expense) (Note 4) | 1 | (28) |
Net interest expense and other financing costs (Note 5) | (221) | (221) |
Income taxes (Note 6) | \underline{(119)} | \underline{ (261)} |
Earnings from continuing operations | 919 | 662 |
Earnings from discontinued operations, net of tax (Note 7) | \underline{201} | \underline{ 272} |
Net earnings | 1,120 | 934 |
Dividends declared on preference shares (Note 16) | \underline{(5)} | \underline{(4)} |
Earnings attributable to common shares | 1,115 | 930 |
Earnings per Common Share (Note 8) | ||
Basic and diluted earnings per common share: | ||
From continuing operations | $1.41 | $1.00 |
From discontinued operations | \underline{0.32} | \underline{0.42} |
Basic and diluted earnings per common share | $1.73 | $1.42 |
As of 31 December 2006 | Cost | Accumulated Amortization | Net Computer Software |
Capitalized software for internal use | 1,791 | (1,228) | 563 |
Capitalized software to be marketed | \underline{212} | \underline{ (128)} | \underline{84} |
2,003 | (1,356) | 647 | |
Capitalized software for internal use | 1,608 | (1,085) | 523 |
Capitalized software to be marketed | \underline{143} | \underline{(98)} | \underline{45} |
1,751 | (1,183) | 568 |
Our explanations are based on the best information we have, but they may not always be right or fit every situation.
Learn more on how we answer questions.