Question 9.7: In Example 9.4 (in Section 9.1), several measurements of the...
In Example 9.4 (in Section 9.1), several measurements of the maximum hourly concentrations (in μg/m³) of SO_2 were presented for each of four power plants, and it was concluded that the mean concentrations at the four plants were not all the same. The following output (from MINITAB) presents the Tukey-Krarner 95% simultaneous confidence intervals for mean concentrations at the four plants. Which pairs of plants, if any, can you conclude with 95% confidence to have differing means?
Tu key 95% Simultaneous Confidence Intervals
All Pairwise Comparisons
Individual confidence level 98.87%
1 subtracted from:
Lower Center Upper – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – – – – +- – – – – – – – -+- – – –
2 109 .4 385.3 661. 1 ( – – – – – – – – – * – – – – – – – – )
3 21.4 312.3 603.1 (- – – – – – – – -*- – – – – – – – )
4 -94.6 170.9 436.4 (- – – – – – – – -*- – – – – – – – )
– – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – –
-300 0 300 600
2 subtracted from:
Lower Center Upper – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – – – – +- – – – – – – – -+- – – –
3 -348.9 -73.0 202.9 ( – – – – – – – – – * – – – – – – – – )
4 -463.4 -214.3 34.7 ( – – – – – – – – – * – – – – – – – – )
– – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – –
-300 0 300 600
3 subtracted from :
Lower Center Upper – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – – – – +- – – – – – – – -+- – – –
4 -406.8 -141.3 124.1 ( – – – – – – – – – * – – – – – – – – )
– – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – – – – – – -+- – – –
-300 0 300 600
Learn more on how we answer questions.
Among the simultaneous confidence intervals, there are two that do not contain 0. These are the intervals for \mu_1 – \mu_2 and for \mu_1 – \mu_3. Therefore we conclude that the mean concentrations differ between plants 1 and 2 and between plants 1 and 3.