Question 9.4: In the article "Review of Development and Application of CRS...

In the article “Review of Development and Application of CRSTER and MPTER Models” (R. Wilson, Atmospheric Environment, 1993:41-57), several measurements of the maximum hourly concentrations (in μg/m³) of SO_2 are presented for each of four power plants. The results are as follows (two outliers have been deleted):

\begin{array}{lrrrrrr}\text{Plant 1:}& 438 & 619 & 732 & 638 & & \\\text{Plant 2:}& 857 & 1014 & 1153 & 883 & 1053 & \\\text{Plant 3:}& 925 & 786 & 1179 & 786 & & \\\text{Plant 4:}& 893 & 891 & 917 & 695 & 675 & 595\end{array}

The following output (from MINITAB) presents results for a one-way ANOVA. Can you conclude that the maximum hourly concentrations differ among the plants?

One- way ANOVA: Plant 1. Plant 2. Plant 3, Plant 4

\begin{array}{lrrrrr}\text{Source}& \text{DF}& \text{SS}& \text{MS}& F & P \\\text{Plant}& 3 & 378610 & 126203 & 6.21 & 0.006 \\\text{Error}& 15 & 304838 & 20323 & & \\\text{Tota1}& 18 & 683449 & & &\end{array}

s = 142 .6           R-Sq = 55 .40%              R-Sq( adj) = 46.48%

Individual 95% Cis For Mean Based on Pooled StDev

\begin{array}{cccc}\text{Leve}& \text{N}& \text{Mean}& \text{StDev}\\1 & 4 & 606.8 & 122.9 \\2 & 5 & 992.0 & 122.7 \\3 & 4 & 919.0 & 185.3 \\4 & 6 & 777.7 & 138.8\end{array}

Pooled StDev = 142. 6

155402-FIGURE 9.4.1
The blue check mark means that this solution has been answered and checked by an expert. This guarantees that the final answer is accurate.
Learn more on how we answer questions.

In the ANOVA table, the P-value for the null hypothesis that all treatment means are equal is 0.006. Therefore we conclude that not all the treatment means are equal.

Related Answered Questions