Question 5.3: The picture shows three men involved in moving a packing cas...
The picture shows three men involved in moving a packing case up to the top floor of a warehouse. Brian is pulling on a rope which passes round smooth pulleys at X and Y and is then secured to the point Z at the end of the loading beam.
The wind is blowing directly towards the building. To counteract this, Eric is pulling on another rope, attached to the packing case at P, with just enough force and in the right direction to keep the packing case central between X and Z.
At the time of the picture the men are holding the packing case motionless.
i) Draw a diagram showing all the forces acting on the packing case using T_{1} and T_{2} for the tensions in Brian and Eric’s ropes, respectively.
ii) Write down equations for the horizontal and vertical equilibrium of the packing
case.
In one particular situation, W = 200, F = 50 , α = 45° and β = 75° .
iii) Find the tension T_{1} .
iv) Explain why Brian has to pull harder if the wind blows stronger.

Learn more on how we answer questions.
i) The diagram shows all the forces acting on the packing case and the relevant angles.
ii) Equilibrium equations
Resolving horizontally ( → )
T_{1} cos β + T_{2} cos α – F – T_{1} cos β = 0
T_{2} cos α – F = 0 ①
Resolving vertically (\uparrow )
T_{1} sin β + T_{1} sin β – T_{2} sin α – W = 0
T_{1} sin β – T_{2} sin α – W = 0 ②
iii) When F = 50 and α = 45° equation ① gives
\begin{matrix}T_{2} cos 45° = 50 & \longleftarrow \boxed{ \text{ This tells you that } T_{2} \text{ is } \frac{50}{cos 45°} \text{ but you don’t need to work it out because }cos 45° = sin 45°.}\end{matrix}
⇒ T_{2} sin 45° = 50
Substituting in ② gives 2T_{1} sin β – 50 – W = 0
So when W = 100 and β = 75° 2T_{1} sin 75° = 150
T_{1} = \frac{150}{2 sin 75°}
The tension in Brian’s rope is 77.65 N = 78 N (to the nearest N).
iv) When the wind blows harder, F increases. Given that all the angles remain unchanged, Eric will have to pull harder so the vertical component of T_{2} will increase. This means that T_{1} must increase and Brian must pull harder.
