The two basic types of steady-flow heat exchanger are characterized by their flow patterns: cocurrent and countercurrent. Temperature profiles for the two types are indicated in Fig. 5.6. In cocurrent flow, heat is transferred from a hot stream, flowing from left to right, to a cold stream flowing

Question

The two basic types of steady-flow heat exchanger are characterized by their flow patterns: cocurrent and countercurrent. Temperature profiles for the two types are indicated in Fig. 5.6. In cocurrent flow, heat is transferred from a hot stream, flowing from left to right, to a cold stream flowing in the same direction, as indicated by arrows. In countercurrent flow, the cold stream, again flowing from left to right, receives heat from the hot stream flowing in the opposite direction.

The lines relate the temperatures of the hot and cold streams, [latex] T_H ext { and } T_C [/latex] respectively, to [latex] \dot{Q}_C [/latex] , the accumulated rate of heat addition to the cold stream as it progresses through the exchanger from the left end to an arbitrary downstream location. The following specifications apply to both cases:

[latex] \begin{array}{llll} T_{H_1}=400 K & T_{H_2}=350 K & T_{C_1}=300 K & \dot{n}_H=1 mol \cdot s ^{-1} \end{array} [/latex]

The minimum temperature difference between the flowing streams is 10 K. Assume the ideal-gas state for both streams with [latex]C_P = (7/2)R [/latex]. Find the lost work for both cases. Take [latex]T_σ = 300 K. [/latex]

Accepted Answer

With the assumption of negligible kinetic- and potential-energy changes, with
[latex] \dot{W}_s=0 ext {, and with } \dot{Q}=0 [/latex] (there is no heat exchange with the surroundings) the energy balance [Eq. (2.29)] can be written:

[latex] \Delta\left[\left(H+\frac{1}{2} u^2+z g ight) \dot{m} ight]_{ fs }=\dot{Q}+\dot{W}_s [/latex] (2.29)

[latex] \dot{n}_H\left(\Delta H^{i g} ight)_H+\dot{n}_C\left(\Delta H^{i g} ight)_C=0 [/latex]

With constant molar heat capacity, this becomes:

[latex] \dot{n}_H C_P^{i g}\left(T_{H_2} - T_{H_1} ight)+\dot{n}_C C_P^{i g}\left(T_{C_2} - T_{C_1} ight)=0 [/latex] (A)

The total rate of entropy change for the flowing streams is:

[latex] \Delta\left(S^{i g} \dot{n} ight)_{ fs }=\dot{n}_H\left(\Delta S^{i g} ight)_H+\dot{n}_C\left(\Delta S^{i g} ight)_C [/latex]

By Eq. (5.10), with the assumption of negligible pressure change in the flowing streams,

[latex] \frac{\Delta S^{i g}}{R}=\int_{T_0}^T \frac{C_P^{i g}}{R} \frac{d T}{T}-\ln \frac{P}{P_0} [/latex] (5.10)

[latex] \Delta\left(S^{i g} \dot{n} ight)_{ fs }=\dot{n}_H C_P^{i g}\left(\ln \frac{T_{H_2}}{T_{H_1}}+\frac{\dot{n}_C}{\dot{n}_H} \ln \frac{T_{C_2}}{T_{C_1}} ight) [/latex] (B)

Finally, by Eq. (5.27), with [latex] \dot{Q}=0 [/latex],

[latex] \dot{W}_{ ext {lost }}=T_\sigma \Delta(S \dot{m})_{ fs } - \dot{Q} [/latex] (5.27)

[latex] \dot{W}_{ ext {lost }}=T_\sigma \Delta(S \dot{m})_{ fs }[/latex] (C)

These equations apply to both cases.

Case I: Cocurrent flow. By Eqs. (A), (B), and (C), respectively:

[latex] \frac{\dot{n}_C}{\dot{n}_H}=\frac{400-350}{340 - 300}=1.25 [/latex]

[latex] \Delta\left(S^{i g} \dot{n} ight)_{ fs }=(1)(7 / 2)(8.314)\left(\ln \frac{350}{400}+1.25 \ln \frac{340}{300} ight)=0.667 J \cdot K ^{-1} \cdot s ^{-1} [/latex]

[latex] \dot{W}_{ ext {lost }}=(300)(0.667)=200.1 J \cdot s ^{-1} [/latex]

Case II: Countercurrent flow. By Eqs. (A), (B), and (C), respectively:

[latex] \frac{\dot{n}_C}{\dot{n}_H}=\frac{400 - 350}{390 - 300}=0.5556 [/latex]

[latex] \Delta\left(S^{i g} \dot{n} ight)_{ fs }=(1)(7 / 2)(8.314)\left(\ln \frac{350}{400}+0.5556 \ln \frac{390}{300} ight)=0.356 J \cdot K ^{-1} \cdot s ^{-1} [/latex]

[latex] \dot{W}_{ ext {lost }}=(300)(0.356)=106.7 J \cdot s ^{-1} [/latex]

Although the total rate of heat transfer is the same for both exchangers, the temperature rise of the cold stream in countercurrent flow is more than twice that for cocurrent flow. Thus, its entropy increase per unit mass is larger than for the cocurrent case. However, its flow rate is less than half that of the cold stream in cocurrent flow, so that the total entropy increase of the cold stream is less for countercurrent flow. From a thermodynamic point of view, the countercurrent case is much more efficient. Because [latex] \Delta\left(S^{i g} \dot{n} ight)_{ fs }=\dot{S}_G [/latex], both the rate of entropy generation and the lost work for the countercurrent case are only about half the value for the cocurrent case. Greater efficiency in the countercurrent case would be anticipated based on Fig. 5.6, which shows that heat is transferred across a smaller temperature difference (less irreversibly) in the countercurrent case.

Question 5.9: The two basic types of steady-flow heat exchanger are charac...

Related Answered Questions

What is the maximum work that can be obtained in a steady-state flow process from 1 mol of nitrogen in its ideal-gas state at 800 K and 50 bar? Take the temperature and pressure of the surroundings as 300 K and 1.0133 bar. ...

Verified Answer:

An inventor claims to have devised a process that takes in only saturated steam at 100°C and which by a complicated series of steps makes heat continuously available at a temperature level of 200°C, with 2000 kJ of energy available at 200°C for every kilogram of steam taken into the process. ...

Verified Answer:

Methane gas at 550 K and 5 bar undergoes a reversible adiabatic expansion to 1 bar. Assuming ideal-gas-state methane at these conditions, find its final temperature. ...

Verified Answer:

Rework Ex. 5.6, making use of the equation for ideal work. ...

Verified Answer:

In a steady-state flow process carried out at atmospheric pressure, 1 mol.s^−1 of air at 600 K is continuously mixed with 2 mol.s^−1 of air at 450 K. The product stream is at 400 K and 1 atm. A schematic representation of the process is shown in Fig. 5.4. Determine the rate of heat transfer ...

Verified Answer:

A 40 kg steel casting (CP = 0.5 kJ⋅kg^−1.K^−1) at a temperature of 450°C is quenched in 150 kg of oil (CP = 2.5 kJ⋅kg^−1⋅K^−1) at 25°C. If there are no heat losses, what is the change in entropy of (a) the casting, (b) the oil, and (c) both considered together? ...

Verified Answer:

A central power plant, rated at 800,000 kW, operates using steam at 585 K and discards heat to a river at 295 K. If the thermal efficiency of the plant is 70% of the maximum possible value, how much heat is discarded to the river at rated power? ...

Verified Answer:

For the ideal-gas state and constant heat capacities, Eq. (3.23b) for a reversible adiabatic (and therefore isentropic) process can be written: T2/T1 = (P2/P1)^(γ−1)/γ Show that this same equation results from application of Eq. (5.10) with ΔS^ig = 0. ...

Verified Answer: