Question 7.63: Prove Alfven’s theorem: In a perfectly conducting fluid (say...

Prove Alfven’s theorem: In a perfectly conducting fluid (say, a gas of free electrons), the magnetic flux through any closed loop moving with the fluid is constant in time. (The magnetic field lines are, as it were, “frozen” into the fluid.)

(a) Use Ohm’s law, in the form of Eq. 7.2, together with Faraday’s law, to prove that if σ = ∞ and J is finite, then

J = σ(E + v × B)                                         (7.2)

\frac{\partial B }{\partial t}=\nabla \times( v \times B ) .

(b) Let S be the surface bounded by the loop (P) at time t, and S ^{\prime} a surface bounded by the loop in its new position (P ^{\prime}) at time t + dt (see Fig. 7.58). The change in flux is

d \Phi=\int_{ S ^{\prime}} B (t+d t) \cdot d a -\int_{ S } B (t) \cdot d a .

Use · B = 0 to show that

\int_{ S ^{\prime}} B (t+d t) \cdot d a +\int_{ R } B (t+d t) \cdot d a =\int_{ S } B (t+d t) \cdot d a

(where R is the “ribbon” joining P and P ^{\prime}), and hence that

d \Phi=d t \int_{ S } \frac{\partial B }{\partial t} \cdot d a -\int_{ R } B (t+d t) \cdot d a

(for infinitesimal dt). Use the method of Sect. 7.1.3 to rewrite the second integral as

d t \oint_{ P }( B \times v ) \cdot d l ,

and invoke Stokes’ theorem to conclude that

\frac{d \Phi}{d t}=\int_{ S }\left(\frac{\partial B }{\partial t}-\nabla \times( v \times B )\right) \cdot d a .

Together with the result in (a), this proves the theorem.

The Blue Check Mark means that this solution has been answered and checked by an expert. This guarantees that the final answer is accurate.
Learn more on how we answer questions.

\text { (a) } J =\sigma( E + v \times B ) ; J \text { finite, } \sigma=\infty \Rightarrow E +( v \times B )=0 . Take the curl: \nabla \times E + \nabla \times( v \times B )= 0 .

But  Faraday’s law says \nabla \times E =-\frac{\partial B }{\partial t} . \quad \text { So } \frac{\partial B }{\partial t}= \nabla \times( v \times B ) . qed 

\text { (b) } \nabla \cdot B =0 \Rightarrow \oint B \cdot d a =0 for any closed surface. Apply this at time (t + dt) to the surface consisting of S, S ^{\prime}, and R:

\int_{ S ^{\prime}} B (t+d t) \cdot d a +\int_{ R } B (t+d t) \cdot d a -\int_{ S } B (t+d t) \cdot d a =0

(the sign change in the third term comes from switching outward da to inward da).

d \Phi=\int_{ S ^{\prime}} B (t+d t) \cdot d a -\int_{ S } B (t) \cdot d a =\int_{ S }[\underbrace{ B (t+d t)- B (t)}_{\frac{\partial B }{\partial t} d t(\text { for infinitesimal } d t)} \cdot d a -\int_{ R } B (t+d t) \cdot d a

 

d \Phi=\left\{\int_{ S } \frac{\partial B }{\partial t} \cdot d a \right\} d t-\int_{ R } B (t+d t) \cdot[(d l \times v ) d t] (Figure 7.13).

ince the second term is already first order in dt, we can replace B(t + dt) by B(t) (the distinction would be second order):

d \Phi=d t \int_{ S } \frac{\partial B }{\partial t} \cdot d a -d t \oint_{ C } \underbrace{ B \cdot(d l \times v )}_{( v \times B ) \cdot d l}=d t\left\{\int_{ S }\left(\frac{\partial B }{\partial t}\right) \cdot d a -\int_{ S } \nabla \times( v \times B ) \cdot d a \right\} .

\frac{d \Phi}{d t}=\int_{ S }\left[\frac{\partial B }{\partial t}- \nabla \times( v \times B )\right] \cdot d a =0 . \quad \text { qed }
7.13

Related Answered Questions