Happiness and Income
A psychologist randomly selected 100 people from each of four income groups and asked them if they were “very happy.” For people who made less than $30,000, 24% responded yes. For people who made $30,000 to $74,999, 33% responded yes. For people who made $75,000 to $90,999, 38% responded yes, and for people who made $100,000 or more, 49% responded yes. At α = 0.05, test the claim that there is no difference in the proportion of people in each economic group who were very happy.
It is necessary to make a table showing the number of people in each group who responded yes and the number of people in each group who responded no.
For group 1, 24% of the people responded yes, so 24% of 100=0.24(100)=24 responded yes and 100−24=76 responded no.
For group 2, 33% of the people responded yes, so 33% of 100=0.33(100)=33 responded yes and 100−33=67 responded no.
For group 3, 38% of the people responded yes, so 38% of 100=0.38(100)=38 people responded yes and 100−38=62 people responded no.
For group 4,49% of the people responded yes, so 49% of 100=0.49(100)=49 responded yes, and 100−49=51 people responded no.
Tabulate the data in a table, and find the sums of the rows and columns as shown.
Household income YesNo Less than $30,0002476100$30,000−$74,9993367100$75,000−$99,9993862100$100,000 or more 4951100Total144256400
Source: Based on information from Princeton Survey Research Associates International.
Step 1 State the hypotheses and identify the claim.
H0:p1=p2=p3=p4 (claim)
H1 : At least one proportion differs from the others.
Step 2 Find the critical value. The formula for the degrees of freedom is the same as before: (R−1)(C−1)=(2−1)(4−1)=1(3)=3. The critical value is 7.815.
Step 3 Compute the test value. Since we want to test the claim that the proportions are equal, we use the expected value as 41⋅400=100. First compute the expected values as shown previously.
E1,1=400(144)(100)=36 E2,1=400(256)(100)=64 E1,2=400(144)(100)=36 E2,2=400(256)(100)=64E1,3=400(144)(100)=36 E2,3=400(256)(100)=64 E1,4=400(144)(100)=36E2,4=400(256)(100)=64The completed table is shown.
Household income YesNo Less than $30,00024(36)76(64)100$30,000−$74,99933(36)67(64)100$75,000−$99,99938(36)62(64)100$100,000 or more 49(36)51(64)100 Total144256400Next calculate the test value.
χ2====∑E(O−E)236(24−36)2+36(33−36)2+36(38−36)2+36(49−36)2+64(76−64)2+64(67−64)2+64(62−64)2+64(51−64)24.000+0.250+0.111+4.694+2.250+0.141+0.063+2.64114.150
Step 4 Make the decision. Reject the null hypothesis since 14.150>7.815. See Figure 11-9.
Step 5 Summarize the results. There is enough evidence to reject the claim that there is no difference in the proportions. Hence, the incomes seem to make a difference in the proportions.