For mappings f,g:R→R and every λ ∈ R define the mappings f + g, f • g and λ f from R to R in the usual way, namely by setting
(f + g)(x)=f(x) +g(x), (f• g)(x)=f(x)g(x),
(λf)(x) = λf(x)
for every x ∈ R.
(a) Show that there are bijections f, g with f + g not a bijection. Show also that there are bijections f, g with f•g not a bijection. Do there exist bijections f,g such that neither f + g nor f•g is a bijection?
(b) Prove that if λ ≠ 0 then λf is a bijection if and only if f is a bijection.
(c) Define [fg] : R→R by [f, g]=f∘g−g∘f. Do there exist bijections f,g with [fg] a bijection?
(d) If 0 denotes the mapping from R to R described by x → 0, prove that, for all mappings f,g,h : R→R,
[[fg]h]+[[gh]f]+[[hf]g]=0.(a) Take, for example, f=idR and g=−idR. Then (f + g)(x) = 0 for every x∈R and so f + g is not a bijection.
Consider now f=idR and define g:R→R by
g(x)={x10 if if x=0;x=0.Then g is a bijection; its graph is shown in Fig. S3.42.
Now
(f⋅g)(x)=f(x)g(x)={x⋅x1=10⋅0=0ifx=0,if x=0;so f·g is not a bijection. For this f and g we also have
(f+g)(x)={x+x10 if if x=0;x=0.The equation x+1/x=1 has no solution in R∗ so there is no x∈R such that (f+g)(x)=1. Thus f + g is not a bijection.
(b) Suppose that f is a bijection. Then for λ=0 we have
(λf)(x1)=(λf)(x2)⇒λf(x1)=λf(x2) ⇒f(x1)=f(x2)⇒x1=x2and so λf is injective. Also, since f is surjective, given any y∈R, there exists t∈R with f(t)=y/λ. Then (λf)(t)=y and hence λf is also surjective. This shows that if f is a bijection then so is λf for every λ=0. Suppose now that λf is a bijection with λ=0. Applying the above result to λf and μ=1/λ, it follows that μ(λf)=(1/λ)(λf)=f is also a bijection.
(c) Consider, for example, the mappings f,g:R→R given byf(x)=x2, g(x)=x+1. We have
[fg](x)=f[g(x)]−g[f(x)] =(x+1)2−(x2+1)=2x,so [fg] is a bijection.
(d) We have
[[fg]h]=[(f∘g−g∘f)h] =(f∘g−g∘f)∘h−h∘(f∘g−g∘f)=f∘g∘h−g∘f∘h−h∘f∘g+h∘g∘fand similarly
Adding these together, we obtain the required result.